Paul McCartney staged a surprise concert at New York’s Bowery Ballroom on Wednesday. Despite the short notice — the former Beatle announced the show at noon that day — several stars including Emma Stone, Anne Hathaway, and supermodel Karlie Kloss managed to attend.

Many guests bundled up to brave the chilly winter weather, with Stone and Kloss favoring leather and suede. Ahead, see the best celebrity looks from McCartney’s unexpected concert.

Anne Hathaway

Hathaway layered a houndstooth peak lapel blazer over a black turtleneck sweater, adding on leather boots, gold rings, and tiny hoop earrings. A taupe wool coat, which she carried outside of the venue, completed her look.

Emma Stone

Stone sported a black leather coat and matching pointed-toe boots, as well as a knit turtleneck and beanie. The “Poor Things” star also accessorized with sheer tights and gold hoop earrings.

Karlie Kloss

Kloss donned a brown suede set from Alexa Chung’s viral collaboration with Madewell. Her look consisted of a double-breasted blazer and a matching miniskirt, which she accessorized with sheer tights and black kitten heels. Like Stone and Hathaway, she also wore a black turtleneck.

Este Haim

Este Haim wore a coordinating set, selecting a taupe zip-up and matching flared trousers. A white top, black boots, and aviator sunglasses topped off her ensemble.

Danielle Haim

Danielle Haim modeled a gray bomber jacket with leather sleeves, layering it over a red sweater and a navy pencil skirt. She also added on a pair of high-heeled black leather boots.

Alana Haim

Alana Haim stepped out in a black aviator jacket, printed midi skirt, and knee-high leather boots. She also carried a black handbag with silver hardware.

Cara Delevingne

Cara Delevingne wore a black aviator jacket, pairing it with a white scoop-neck top, wide-leg dark wash jeans, and black loafers.